#snes on irc.freenode.netStar Fox 2
2010 marks the 15th anniversary of the non-release of the highly anticipated sequel to Star Fox. By the middle of 1995, it was apparent that despite favourable reviews at the Winter 1995 CES, Nintendo was hesitant to release Star Fox 2 against the superior looking Saturn and PlayStation. The impending launch of the Nintendo 64 also played a part in its cancellation, with Nintendo wanting a clear break between Super FX 3D and N64 3D. Although Nintendo claimed it would be released in the September 1995 issue of Nintendo Power, it was swept under the rug along with other Super FX games like Comanche and FX Fighter. Through the course of time, alpha and near final beta ROM images were leaked. Despite its cancellation, Star Fox 2 remains a highly revered game for its excellent gameplay and intriguing history.
The Rise and Fall of the Super FX Spectacle
The development of Star Fox 2 began almost immediately after the original was finished. As the above code comment states, Star Fox 2 began development on February 16, 1993, a mere five days before the Japanese release of the original, if Wikipedia is to be trusted (more on the code later). The first mention in the press that I found was from the January 1994 issue of Game Players, stating the game would feature split screen multiplayer and use the Super FX2 chip. The first public statement on the development of Star Fox 2 was in a rec.games.video.nintendo Usenet post in February 1994 by Dylan Cuthbert stating that it would continue to use polygons (it also mentions Elite's unreleased Super FX game, Powerslide). Aside from that, all mentions of Star Fox 2 in 1994 were generally speculation and rumours.
The first display of Star Fox 2 by Nintendo was at the 1995 Winter CES in Las Vegas. With the delay of the then "Ultra 64", Nintendo decided to push several Super FX games (Star Fox 2, FX Fighter, Comanche, all of which were eventually cancelled) along with the unveiling of the Virtual Boy to keep attention focused their way. Really, the Winter CES show was generally a disappointment, as most companies were biding their time until the first E3 that May. It seems appropriate that the biggest games and hardware that Nintendo showed at the WCES were disappointments, second rate fare or never released. However, Star Fox 2 was generally praised by those in attendance, and reports from the CES state that the Star Fox 2 demos were always in use. The reception in the press ranged from glee (Total!, EGM), to derision (Edge). Those who were excited about the game praised the freedom of motion in levels and the new walker mode. Given the response, everything seemed to be set for the promised summer 1995 release of the game. The game was so popular, a man named Shawn J. Freeman was arrested for attempting to steal the game (probably leading to the incorrect assumption that the subsequent leaked ROMs were from the CES show)!
However, it never happened. Rumours showed up as early as April 1995 that the game had been delayed until 1996 so that it did not clash with the release of the Nintendo 64 and Virtual Boy (or even that the game had to be retooled - though this certainly was not true). The game was not shown at the inaugural E3 in May 1995. Instead, Nintendo showed off the final version of the Ultra 64 hardware, along with the Virtual Boy and Donkey Kong Country 2. In the letters section of the September issue of EGM (presumably published in August), the editor wrote that Star Fox 2 was cancelled. In the September 1995 issue of Nintendo Power, they countered that claim stating:
Rumors of the demise of Star Fox 2 have been greatly exaggerated. Development of Nintendo's sequel to the hit 3-D space action game is finishing as we go to press. The big question mark is the release date, most likely in the first half of '96. The most recent versions of Star Fox 2 look very sharp and include a much more strategic feel, with radar windows and mother ships where you dock after battle.
That was the last official word we heard about Star Fox 2 for the SNES. In early 1996, Nintendo showed off what would become Star Fox 64 on the Nintendo 64, putting the final nail in Star Fox 2's coffin. Though there are claims that the high cost of producing Super FX games may have led to the delay and cancellation of the game, it seems that the main reason was that Nintendo felt it was going to be released too close to the release of the Nintendo 64. This is a quote from programmer Dylan Cuthbert from the defunct website emulatorium.com:
What happened to Star Fox 2? Why was it cancelled and how far into development was it? How is it, if at all, related to Star Fox 64?
From the timing of the statement in Nintendo, it appears that Star Fox 2 was completed in Summer 1995 (the "final" beta that was leaked has a time stamp of June 22, 1995 inside the test mode menu). Although the impending release of the Nintendo 64 factored into the decision to cancel the game, I'm sure the impressive release of the PlayStation also factored into it. Despite sporting excellent gameplay that outshone most Saturn and PlayStation games released in 1995, the graphics were definitely not impressive in comparison.
Though Star Fox 2 did not come out, it did influence subsequent Nintendo games. Miyamoto stated many of the ideas and technology for the 3D environment from Super Mario 64 came during the development of Star Fox (and probably Star Fox 2 as well). Miyamoto claimed about 30% of the ideas in Star Fox 64 came from Star Fox 2 (in all likelihood referring to the all-range mode battles, Star Wolf team and the tank levels). Dylan Cuthbert stated the strategic elements from Star Fox Command for the DS were inspired by Star Fox 2.
Were it not for the Internet, that might have been the last we heard about Star Fox 2. Though there were still occasional comments about Star Fox 2 on Usenet in 1996 and 1997, it was increasingly clear that Star Fox 2 was not officially coming out. The blossoming SNES emulation scene in the late 90s became an outlet for the proliferation of many unreleased and beta games that would have never seen the light of day. Though website archives at Archive.org are incomplete, I noted that Cherryroms.com (a large SNES ROM site back then) took Star Fox 2 off their "undumped" list between May 1999 and September 1999. This could only mean that the early "multiplayer" alpha leaked sometime between those dates. This alpha certainly piqued the interest of SNES fan-sites such as SNESZone and The SNES Site (an early incarnation of SNES Central, certainly my writing and analysis has improved since then) who produced articles about it. It was clear that this was only an internal development alpha, as even the version of Star Fox 2 shown at the Winter CES was far further along in development than this alpha.
The real blockbuster, which served as the pinnacle of the SNES emulation scene, in my opinion, was the release of the final beta of Star Fox 2 in August 2002 (well documented by d4s in this FAQ, who also had a big hand in the discovery of the ROM image). The first screenshots appeared on the now defunct website, sportkompaktwoche.de. The ROM itself needed several fixes (made by The Dumper) before it could play in emulators, though there were accusations that it was a fake before that happened. The unfixed ROM was leaked by "skyhawk" of the German fan translation site, Alemanic Translations. Apparently skyhawk claimed to have found this game on a prototype cart and dumped it himself, probably leading to the widespread belief this game was found off a prototype cart. In reality, Star Fox 2 was leaked as a pure assembled binary from a former developer who wanted the game emulated, and the ROM was not in a proper SNES ROM format initially. There was no source code leaked, nor was there ever a prototype or production cart of it. Soon after the leak of Star Fox 2, emulator authors incorporated proper Super FX emulation, allowing the general community to play the game in all its glory.
The final part of the Star Fox 2 story is the fan translation. Though it was clear English text versions of this game existed (look at screenshots taken from the game at the Winter 1995 CES), the leaked final beta was entirely in Japanese. In 2004, the hacking/translation team of Gideon Zhi, d4s, Fusoya and satsu from Aeon Genesis translated the game to English, and removed all the debugger information and cheats that were the last remnants of the beta status of the game. Essentially they finished up the game to what the final version might have looked like. The completed translation has become the fodder for many bootleggers making "reproduction" carts that have fooled more than one person into thinking the game actually did come out.
I managed to get my hands on some source code for Star Fox 2. I was asked not to distribute the code, and I will respect that. The source code originated from a programmer at a British game company that produced computer games in the early 90s, but does not have any obvious connection with Argonaut. There are three archives of the source code, dating from April-May 1994. Star Fox 2 was programmed on an OS/2 operating system. There are not many real goodies of interest to the general reader (it is mostly straight ahead assembly, with few comments). Argonaut used their own custom assembler called ARGSFXX. The graphics files are in a customized binary format that I did not feel like attempting to crack.
The earliest source archive in this set dates to April 15, 1994. This archive also (to my surprise) contained a ROM in it. After scanning it, it turned out to the early alpha ROM, solving the mystery as to where it came from! There is a lot of legacy code in this archive as well, including some code from a Super NES version of StarGlider (which became Star Fox).
The second set of source code dates to May 6, 1994. It has most of the same files as the April 15 archive, but does have added level files, including training levels and one entitled "room". Unfortunately, there aren't any binaries in this archive.
The third archive dates to May 13, 1994. The levels code was pretty much unchanged from the previous archive. There are binary files in this archive, but unfortunately the are not linked together. It might be possible to combine them to make a SNES ROM, but that is beyond my level of expertise.
At this point, there are two known leaked prototypes of Star Fox 2: an early alpha and final beta. There are plenty of mentions about a third, even earlier alpha, even referenced on the old version of this page. However after analysis, the really early alpha turned out to not even be a SNES ROM. In addition, there are two prototype version of the game shown to the media, one was from a preview in Nintendo Power, the other was the version shown at the 1995 Winter CES.
The early alpha originated from the source code mentioned earlier. There is no record of when it originally leaked on the Internet, but looking at FAQs from Cherryroms.com, it must have been leaked sometime between May and September 1999. The ROM itself is rather buggy, and flickers on real hardware (if this video is actually being played on real hardware). The game gives a black screen if loaded in bsnes or snes9x 1.52, and flickers a lot on zsnes 1.51. This is a case where better emulation hampered how well the game runs. If you want to play this game with minimal problems, I suggest using zsnes 1.337, which runs without any flickering or sound issues.
Despite the alpha feel to this build (once you win a level, the game basically freezes and you have to reset), the 3D navigational aspects of this game are certainly approaching completion. The Arwing also is able to transform into a walker in land-based levels (which is in the final version), and this "hover" style craft in space-based levels. The hover mode never made it into the final version, probably because it is a bit difficult to control. Many of the land-based levels have N-E-S-W markers so you can tell what direction you are going. All the enemies and objects in the level (except bosses that show up) are bounded to a square area on the radar screen, though you can keep going outside of this boundary. If you go far enough, you loop around to the other side. The control scheme is the same as in the first Star Fox game (they switched the fire button from "Y" to "B" in the final version). Also notable is that acceleration/braking causes your ship to overheat for a short while if you hit the limit of the bar. The programming for the walker does not seem complete, as it moves very slowly. The music is very nice, but I did not immediately recognize any of the songs being in either Star Fox or the final beta of Star Fox 2.
In the "Mission" mode, you have the choice between Fox, Slippy, Peppy, Falco, Saru and Lady (the latter two were changed to Miyu and Fay in the final beta). Each Arwing has a distinct design, though they control and act the same. There are nine levels to select from, with varying amounts of enemies and objects, but generally pretty simplistic if compared with the final beta. Here is a summary:
In the two player battle mode, you have the choice between six characters: Fox, Slippy, Peppy, Falco, Andross and a female (?) fox character. There are five levels: two ground, two space and marine. The radar has a white marker where your opponent is. Once one person is defeated, the winning ship flies off, and you must reset. The multiplayer mode actually works quite well, with no slowdown, although it is easy to see that it could be pretty boring after a few attempts.
The test mode has five levels, plus an option to choose from various different programmers (maybe to write who did the test in the debugger?) The marine stage allows your walker to go into a "swimming" mode, though you can only go upwards. The levels are empty except for rings. There are Ground, Desert, Marine and Space levels, and you can choose one or two player modes.
There are two modes in training: type and train. The "type" mode is a single screen thing that might be an explanation screen for various parts of the game. The Arwing flies in a dark screen where random ostrich enemies appear and can be shot. The "train" mode shows the ground level, with an explanation of the controls on screen, plus the alphabet and numbers on the right side, which I can only assume are filler for future content.
Finally, the config mode has options for stereo and mono sound, plus a sound test (which doesn't appear to work). Not much else to say about that.
In summary, the alpha appears to have most of the game engine for Star Fox 2 finished, but the levels and enemies are in a very early state. There was no programming to return the player to the menu after defeating the bosses and debugger information is displayed while playing. The two player battle mode works quite well and has a fox character that is not in the final beta.
November 25, 1994 beta
Nintendo Power had an "exclusive" preview of Star Fox 2 in their February 1994 issue. It is far more advanced in development than the alpha ROM. In this version, there is a very plain, almost squared off map. The third transformation of the Arwing still exists in this beta. The game appears to have a lot of polish at this point. The start menu screen is different than the CES beta with the game titled "Star Fox II" and displays Andross and a goat character that is not in the final version.
1995 Winter CES beta
This beta was shown at the 1995 Winter CES in January 1995, and was the centrepiece of Nintendo's display since the "Ultra 64" was only shown behind closed doors. Most descriptions of the WCES event say that the Star Fox 2 units were always busy. The beta was impressive enough to make the cover of Total! magazine in the UK (with a nice description of the display at the WCES), and a multi-page preview in Electronic Gaming Monthly (which has more pictures than any other magazine). Several shots found in magazines are the same, so I assume that these come from a media package distributed by Nintendo at the WCES.
From the looks of the pictures, the gameplay engine was complete by this point. The interface of the game is not much different from the final beta. One thing of note is that the CES beta has English text. The characters in the WCES beta appear to be finalized, though the title screen uses different artwork from the final beta. The title screen also indicates a change from Roman to Arabic numerals for the title. The WCES beta had a different map screen than the 94-11-25 beta, and lacks the Macbeth and Fortuna levels that are in the final version. The map icons for enemy types also differ from the the final beta. It also looks like the space battle scenes are in a third person view, rather than a first person view like in the final beta. The introductory screen for levels shows that the targets to open up the base differed in the WCES beta and the level layouts were not the same. I did not see any screenshots of the "hover" transformation of the Arwing, indicating it might have been cut by the WCES. Overall, the game seemed to be coming together by the Winter CES showing, and mostly just needed additional levels to complete development.
The final beta of Star Fox 2 is the culmination of a nearly two and a half year development process to take the game from an on-the-rails shooter to a fully 3D experience. The game is pretty much in a final state, though the framerate counter, several debugger modes, and some hard coded cheats indicate that this beta was not the final production version.
When this final beta was leaked, many were not convinced that it was as near final as claimed. Due to the incomplete nature of Super FX emulation in mid 2002, the game had a flickering screen and tended to freeze. Here is what I said in an article that I wrote on September 22, 2002, after the beta leaked:
Despite what others say, I disagree with people saying that it was a "final" beta. This game had a few levels in the story mode that took place in space, but due to a particularly annoying bug, proceeding very far in the game is very difficult. The bug makes it so that Star Wolf characters attack you at every small movement on the map, but you can't actually attack them unless you are very close to their ship on the map (and often you aren't). Also, when you are fighting in levels, quite often your ship disappears and the camera freezes in place, making you have to reset the game. Also, there is test levels for using a Star Wars-like walker, but in general, these stages are quite buggy and the game randomly crashes. I seriously doubt these bugs are from the lack of Super FX emulation. To me, it seems like the game engine for the free-range mode stages was complete, but the walker stages were not. If you ask me, this beta stands as a 75% complete game at best. I will try it again once the next version of Zsnes comes out and see if any of these bugs were fixed.
Of course, I was completely wrong in my assessment, and I eventually had to eat crow. Once the emulation bugs were fixed, Star Fox 2 became completely playable with no bugs. It is true that the levels in the debugger modes are glitchy and prone to crashing, however these have no bearing on the mission modes.
Speaking of the test modes, there are a few things in the menu of the final beta that should be noted. The "Test" menu brings you to a selection of levels, some of which are obviously not in the final mission mode. The planetary and battleship missions tend to have no real ending when you defeat the core of the base (you can crash into the core to kill yourself). There were a couple of Andross battle modes. I found after beating one of the Andross levels that the sound started to glitch (it just kept repeating samples of the characters talking at the end). Also, your health doesn't replenish between levels, so if you die in one, you are left with no health in the next test level. Before starting each test level, there is a "planet step", which can be set to different numbers to take you to different parts of the stage. Your Arwing is orange coloured in the test modes, and the character you use seems to be be random. The Practise mode seems to just be the "easy" mode, except Corneria doesn't take damage, you have two Fox Arwings, and they are coloured orange. There seems to be little else different, as the scores in the training mode and the General Pepper coins are saved in the records. The config mode allows you to change the sound from stereo to mono, and also has a sound test. In the main game, there is a cheat that makes it so Corneria does not take damage, making the game rather lacking in challenge.
Thanks to the efforts of Aeon Genesis, Star Fox 2 was fully translated to English and the last of the bugs/cheats (i.e. the bug where the Arwing can transform in space levels and Corneria not getting damage when attacked) were fixed. The translation patch came out on October 17, 2004, over two years after the beta was leaked onto the Internet. Even at that point emulators had trouble running the game, though it appears that zsnes 1.40 came out a couple of months later with support. I'll admit that I never got around to playing the patch until I started the article, which probably is why I never updated this page for years and incorrect information was allowed to perpetuate (many of the pieces of incorrect information on the Wikipedia page for Star Fox 2 appear to have come from the old article). I think the translation is excellent, though admittedly Star Fox 2 is not the most story driven game. The patch gives the game a nice bit of polish to make it look like it would have if it was released.
Star Fox 2 is an excellent game, and I think it would definitely make my top 20 favourite SNES games. This game corrects pretty much all of the complaints from the first game (lack of range of motion, poor frame rate, lack of aiming cursor), and upped the intensity level. Though some might be disappointed they cut the two player multiplayer mode (which existed in the Winter CES beta), the excellent single player mode more than makes up for it.
Star Fox 2 is more than just a straight ahead shooter like its predecessor. The game runs in a semi-real time mode, with the forces of Andross closing in to destroy the planet of Corneria. Your force (two Arwings that can be changed at any point on the map screen) flies around the map, while you encounter ships, rockets and planets that are occupied by Andross. The game is split up into three difficulty levels. Rather than just increasing the amount or hit points of enemies when increasing the difficulty levels, the amount of planets needed to be rescued also increases, and the level layouts become more complex. On "normal" difficulty, only two planets need to be saved, two battleships need destroyed, and the levels are very straight forward. In "Expert" difficulty, six planets need saved, four battleships need destroyed, and the levels are complex and have bosses in them. I found the "normal" and "hard" modes were fairly easy to beat, and I passed them first try. On "expert", it really becomes crucial to manage the assault on Corneria and beat levels quickly or the planet quickly takes too much damage. Since the Mothership can heal your ships, the main challenge is protecting the planet.
The battles in Star Fox 2 are split between first person sections in space and third person planetary and battleship levels. The space sections have you doing dog fights against other ships (including the rival Star Wolf gang). The planet and battleship levels allow you to switch between the Arwing and walker modes on the fly. On planets, you have to step on trigger switches to raise the base from the ground. Once inside the base or battleship, you usually have to solve a maze or defeat a boss to gain access to the energy core. Thankfully, they added a cross-hair to make aiming more precise and the ability to lock on and shoot a charged energy blast at enemies.
Character selection is key to success in this game. Each character has strengths and weaknesses, making it key to pick a character that suits your playing style. For instance, Slippy and Peppy's Arwings are tanks that can take more hits than any other character, but have a much longer charge time for the energy blast and are slow moving. Miyu and Fay are the opposite; they have the weakest Arwing but can shoot off several charged blasts in the time it would take for Slippy and Peppy to shoot one. They also start with the twin lasers making them and offencive powerhouses from the get go. Falco and Fox have statistics between these extremes.
Now for the nitpicking section. The game has great graphics for a Super FX game. The obstacles in planet levels have textures on them, and the backgrounds are detailed. A nice added touch in the space levels are that the backgrounds reflect the location on the map where you fight the enemy. The framerate is better than in Star Fox, though it does tend to slow down if there is a lot of action on screen. The music is top notch, as you might expect from a Nintendo developed game. The control scheme rotated the face buttons by a quarter turn counterclockwise from the first game. The only complaints I have about the controls are that the cross-hair doesn't automatically reset to the centre of the screen in first person levels, leading to a bit of frustration in Star Wolf battles. Additionally, turning the walker is a bit slow, though this is likely dictated by the frame rate.
Overall, the final beta of Star Fox 2 is a lot of fun. I found the dogfight battles to be very intense and exciting. The expert mode takes about an hour to pass. The main replay value comes in trying to get higher scores. Additionally, there are General Pepper medallions in all the levels that you can search out. Once collected, they do not appear in future playthoughs.
Star Fox 2 is one of the best Super NES games, and it is a shame that it never officially got released. Although several aspects of Star Fox 2 made it into Star Fox 64, this game has a much different feel and seems more intense. At the very least, the two and a half years developing this game did not go to complete waste and we can now enjoy the fruits of this first party title with the aid of emulators. I even found myself playing the game for an hour when all I wanted was a single screenshot of a level, which should give you an idea of how great the gameplay is. Star Fox 2 played a large role in the development of fully 3D Nintendo titles on the Nintendo 64 and serves as an interesting footnote in the history of the Super NES. Star Fox 2 is still considered one of the most enduring vaporware titles and one of the most interesting stories of the Super NES.
|© Evan G. This site made by a Canadian, and fueled by beer. Do not use material on this site without permission.|